by Benjamin Lund, Editor, Orthotown Magazine
Raise your hand if you're a fan of treating
malocclusions and difficult tooth movements
in a predictable fashion, or even of moving
specific teeth while minimizing the movement
of others. Then you've got to love temporary
anchorage devices (aka, TADs), right?
These tiny, simple screws have revolutionized
modern orthodontics and have steadily
become a staple in orthodontic practice and
residency programs.
Orthotown Magazine reached out to several
leading manufacturers of TADs to get a snapshot
on the current state of TAD usage in the
orthodontic profession.
From your perspective, have you seen an increase or decrease
in TAD usage over the last year?
Jamie Morness, global product manager, 3M Unitek: Over the last
year, market data shows the use of TADs has declined slightly. However, this
trend is somewhat regional, with the Asia region continuing to show growth.
Dan Lopez, mini-implants product manager, American Orthodontics:
American Orthodontics is seeing some growth in regard to TADs. In the coming
years, there might be a gradual increase as a result of younger orthodontists
who become increasingly familiar with TAD placement during residency.
Craig Beach, general manager, Dentaurum USA: We have experienced
high growth rates over the past seven years, however, we have seen this
growth level off in the past 12-18 months. Some of this slow-down effect is
due to the struggling economy and the pressure to provide lower treatment
fees. TADs obviously add cost for the patient, so this can be a more difficult
"sell-through" during a consultation with a patient in this economy. The
economy is one reason, but we feel the main reason for the decrease in TAD
usage is that many companies are selling starter kits without any guidelines
for success or without "hands-on" training, and this has resulted in many
doctors experiencing high failure rates. Obviously, when TADs fail it is very
frustrating for the doctor and also for the patient, so these high failure rates
have caused many doctors to become less enthusiastic about using TADs on
their next patient.
Karri Denny, marketing coordinator, Forestadent USA: We have seen
an increase in the usage of TADs in the residency programs, so the residents are getting in-depth instruction and hands-on practical experience while they
are in school, and when they graduate they are very comfortable incorporating
TADs into their treatment. As a result, we predict that TAD usage will
increase drastically in 2014 and beyond.
Joe Panara, AbsoAnchor product manager, Great Lakes Orthodontics,
Ltd.: An increasing number of doctors, and specifically orthodontists, have
become trained and more comfortable placing micro implants. The market
is continuing to grow.
Ortho Organizers: There has been a decrease in the use of TADs especially
domestically and in Europe over the past year. The first half of 2012
has also shown a decrease over the first half of 2011 in this market segment.
Jobe Dubbs, director of marketing, Ormco: Over the past year, we've
seen consistent usage of our VectorTAS product in North America, while
experiencing greater adaptation in Asia.
Do you think doctors are becoming more comfortable with the
idea of placing TADs?
Morness: When looking at the lecture schedules of many of the industry
events, TADs continue to have a strong interest and attendance. I think because orthodontic manufacturers have continued to offer TAD training
courses, and as more residents are learning about TADs during their residency,
the awareness of TAD systems and doctors' comfort level with placement
is increasing.
Lopez: Yes. In addition to orthodontists becoming more comfortable
with TAD placement due to research confirming them as a proven technology,
the younger generation of orthodontists is embracing them, as residents
are now often exposed to placing TADs during their residency.
Beach: Yes, we have seen a huge shift in this area over the past five years. I
would estimate that approximately 80 percent of orthodontists are now placing
their own TADs, and about 20 percent are still referring them out. This
is compared to about five years ago, when only approximately 15 percent of
orthodontists were placing their own TADs. Orthodontists have found that
referring out TAD placements can result in disadvantages from poor communication
on TAD location or angle of insertion, higher cost to the patient and
lower patient acceptance rates.
Dentsply GAC: Yes. Especially orthodontists who now routinely have
access to TADs during the course of their schooling, and the prevalence of
hands-on TAD courses.
Denny: Since it is still a relatively new treatment, there is still a little hesitation
for doctors across the country, but in my experience, most of them are
looking to find ways to expand their treatment offerings and make their
treatments more efficient. So they are taking the time to become informed,
and attending courses to become more proficient and comfortable in TAD
placement in order to incorporate this treatment into their practice.
Panara: Yes, doctors are becoming more comfortable placing micro
implants. In addition, many university residents are now learning and
training with TADs, and beginning their practices using micro implants in
their treatments.
Ortho Organizers: Yes, as companies have provided more courses on
TADs, they have also provided hands-on workshops whereby the doctors are
able to place TADs on one another. This has helped specialists overcome their
hesitancies in placing TADs.
Dubbs: Yes. According to Dr. Scheffler, today many leading orthodontists
use TADs as part of routine orthodontic treatment.
What typical treatment plans are you aware of that TADs make
"easier" for the clinician?
Morness: Indications for TADs have a wide range. They are useful for
space closure, tooth uprighting, open bite correction, molar distalization and
a number of other applications.
Lopez: The treatment plans that come to mind are molar mesialization
and distalization, molar uprighting, intrusion, indirect anchorage, en masse
retraction and molar protraction.
Beach: [In addition to the top indications for TADs] recently we have
even seen a big increase in doctors using TADs as temporary implants versus
forcing patients to wear a "flipper" or some other device that needs to
be removed while eating. These cases mentioned above are all cases that
provide challenges to the orthodontists, and without the help of a TAD,
the patient will endure longer treatment times and less comfortable alternatives
like surgery, Class II correctors, headgear and other appliances that
depend on patient compliance. If TADs are placed with good success, then the majority of patients will jump at the chance to choose a TAD versus
these alternatives.
Dentsply GAC: Many routine cases can be made easier with the use
of TADs due to additional anchorage control and more predictable outcomes.
However, the types of cases where we see TADs making the greatest
contribution to treatment are: adult cases, especially those which
require substantial tooth movements; limited anchorage: hypodontia premature
tooth loss/reduced root support; molar intrusion for anterior open
bite cases; molar protraction and distalisation; centerline corrections; and
single tooth intrusions.
Denny: TADs provide excellent anchorage mechanics, which offer the
clinician a variety of treatment options. Implementing TADs can help with
the following treatments: space closure, mesialization, distalization, intrusion
and vertical displacement.
Panara: There are several reasons why micro-implant treatment, in many
cases, could be considered better, easier and faster than traditional treatment
for both the patient and the doctor. Prominent examples include: molar
intrusion, tilted molar uprighting and retraction of maxillary/mandibular
anterior dentitions.
Ortho Organizers: TADs are wonderful in conjunction with the Carriere
Distalizer Appliance as it is an easy source of anchorage for distalizing the
canine to first molar segment.
Dubbs: TADs have been shown to be particularly useful for cases requiring
anchorage, anterior open bite correction, gummy smile correction, edentulous
space closure, segmental intrusion/extrusion, occlusal cant correction
and molar uprighting.
In your opinion, why should more doctors start placing TADs?
Morness: TADs offer a fixed anchorage option to assist the efficiency of
orthodontic treatment and can be used in a number of cases. There are even
some cases where patients are unable or unwilling to undergo surgical treatment;
in these situations, TADs could be an alternative.
Lopez: Adult treatment has presented some very difficult situations that
require alternative methods of establishing proper anchorage. TADs have
made it possible for orthodontists to coordinate treatment without the associated
concerns of tooth-to-tooth anchorage.
Beach: In all honesty, our goal is not to get more doctors to place more
TADs - our goal is to get our existing users to place their TADs more successfully!
I think if we are able to achieve this goal, then the number of
TADs sold should be an afterthought. There is no disagreement among
orthodontists about the vast level of clinical advantages that TADs offer,
but in order to see those advantages, the TADs must work successfully on
a consistent basis.
Dentsply GAC: TADs offer the following advantages: minimal requirement
for patient compliance, flexible timing, greater predictability and outcomes,
reduced treatment times, 3D anchorage and they are ideal for adults.
Denny: If there are ways to help improve productivity, efficiency and the
overall satisfaction outcome of their service, then that idea should be
explored. TAD treatment can affect all three of these areas of a clinician's
practice by simply allowing treatment to progress faster and more efficiently.
Panara: Using orthodontic micro implants gives doctors a technological
advantage using directional force mechanics to improve dentition, dental function and dental appearance. Micro implants, in many cases,
can make treatment better, easier and faster for both the patient
and doctor.
Ortho Organizers: It's easy, it can all happen in one short
appointment with precise placement, exactly where you want it,
and with immediately loading. What else can you ask for? Why
refer it out to your oral surgeon when you can do it yourself?
Dubbs: TADs offer professionals the ability to treat difficult
cases with non-surgical or non-extraction treatment plans.
Working with TADs removes unwanted reciprocal forces, allowing
simple cases to be treated more quickly, and puts compliance
in the hands of the orthodontist, rather than the patient.
What kind of training does your company offer when
it comes to TAD placement
Morness: We have a number of training opportunities for
doctors to familiarize themselves with the Unitek Temporary
Anchorage Device System. The most hands-on training
approach is Dr. Jason Cope's in-office courses. He leads two separate
courses for both beginner and advanced users. We also
have a Webinar, presented by Dr. Mohammad Razavi, on the
use of the Unitek TAD for palatal anchorage to control vertical
dimension and correction of anterior open bites. CE is also
offered at our various user meetings and at other lectures by Drs.
Cope and Razavi.
Lopez: American Orthodontics offers multiple training
opportunities for the Aarhus System, ranging from full course
lectures by system founder and premier researcher Professor
Birte Melsen, to in-office, hands-on training featuring an effective
demonstration kit.
Beach: We offer several different TAD Clinical Reference
Guides, which provide step-by-step instructions on how to place
and use TADs with all the "challenging indications" that an
orthodontist faces. Also, we are the only company offering a full tomas auxiliary kit that provides time-saving, customized TAD
auxiliaries for easier and more efficient treatment. Regarding
education, we offer seminars at our AAO booth, a one-day seminar
series throughout the country and also our TAD User
Forum which is always held in Vegas and is now in its fourth
year with more than 300 doctors attending this year!
Dentsply GAC: Hands-on training, accredited TAD courses
and supplemental educational materials.
Denny: We offer various training programs in the U.S. and
abroad, featuring some of the leading experts on TAD treatment.
The training sessions range from lectures featuring treatment
planning using TADs and mechanics to practical hands-on
placement of TADs in a clinical setting. All of which are
extremely beneficial for a doctor looking to start a TAD regimen
in their practice or for the seasoned expert looking for new ideas
in TAD treatment.
Panara: Great Lakes sponsors a full-day seminar once a year
just prior to the annual AAO in May. This year's conference was
the seventh Annual World Micro Implant Anchorage [WMIA]
Congress. This seminar features many of the doctors responsible
for designing the AbsoAnchor System, as well as the pioneers
and experienced users of micro-implant anchorage around the
world. We also sponsor micro-implant courses for study clubs
and dental/orthodontic organizations.
Dubbs: Ormco offers live seminars with hands-on placement
training and Webinars for ongoing VectorTAS educational
support. In addition, many of the classes offered are accompanied
by a comprehensive "how to" workbook for orthodontists
to reference. Dr. Nicole Scheffler, co-creator of VectorTAS,
commented that support for the appliance is multi-faceted, with
full-day course trainings available, including instruction for
proper TADs placement on patients, as well as Webinars and
access to leading orthodontists who can answer specific treatment
questions.
3M Unitek
The uniqueness of the Unitek Temporary
Anchorage Device (TAD) System is in its simplicity:
a one-head design, with one-size diameter
and three different lengths, thus making
it simple to understand and use. The selfdrilling
and self-tapping design allows for an
installation procedure that can be done in one
appointment with no pilot hole and can be
loaded with an attachment immediately. Visit solutions.3m.com/wps/portal/3M/en_US/orthodontics/Unitek for more information.
|
American Orthodontics
The American Orthodontics
Aarhus System offers a
user-friendly mini-implant
screw that delivers safe and
consistent treatment and a
complete line of accessories. The high quality TAD system
delivers the perfect balance of strength and working
diameter, with premium high strength titanium alloy
noted for its biocompatibility and resistance to corrosion.
Visit www.americanortho.com for more information.
|
Dentaurum USA
The tomas TAD offers a patented
"cross-slot and undercut" head
design for easy, versatile and efficient
treatment of all TAD cases with
one universal head design. Whether you
prefer using TAD mechanics with elastics,
coil springs or SS stabilization wires, the
tomas pin provides many different treatment
alternatives for each case. Dentaurum is also
the only supplier that offers a complete TAD
Auxiliary Kit & Clinical Reference Guide. Visit
www.tomasforum.com for more information.
|
Dentsply GAC
The Infinitas Mini Implant System is a versatile TAD. Its
unique multi-purpose head design accommodates direct
attachment of many forms of traction. The body has a
full-length cutting thread and is tapered, designed for
increased stability. The angled transmucosal
neck is designed for insertion at any
angle. Infinitas uses a self-drilling insertion
technique, to ease insertion and
maximize stability. Available system
kits: Introductory Clinical Kit (sterile/
non-sterile); Complete Clinical Kit
(sterile/non-sterile); Guidance
Kit. Visit www.gacintl.com for
more information.
|
Forestadent USA
From the innovative screw design, inspired by some of the
leading TAD experts, to the high quality material make-up,
the OrthoEasy Mini Screw effectively delivers excellent
outcomes in a variety of clinical treatments. Features
include an innovative octangular head, three color-coded
lengths and shark-like cuts. Visit www.forestadent.com for more information.
|
Ormco
VectorTAS - designed for treating
anterior open bites, occlusal cant and
molar intrusion - provides clinicians with a fast, effective
means to treat a full range of orthodontic cases without
compensating for the inadvertent reciprocal movement of
adjacent teeth. Designed by orthodontists specifically for
orthodontic use, VectorTAS is a coordinated system of
mini screws, attachments and instruments that provide
clinicians with all the benefits of temporary anchorage.
Visit www.ormco.com for more information.
|
Ortho Organizers
The Orlus Mini Screw features a unique
design that is easy to use and is designed
for enhanced stability and clinical efficiency.
Additionally, it is not technique-dependent,
not site-dependent and minimizes the
influence of bone-dependent conditions.
Visit www.orthoorganizers.com for more
information.
|
Ortho Technology
The Spider Screw Temporary Anchorage Device screw
head has an easy open, easy close design with a slot for
wires up to .018" x .022", and an under-tie-wing for additional
anchorage. The patented design offers a conical
thread, allowing the Spider Screw to
be self-drilling and self-tapping, eliminating
drilling in most applications.
Visit www.orthotechnology.com/tads for more information.
|
|